Should you hire window installers as employees or use subcontractors?
You may end up with some of each, but decide which one runs your normal week. Your own crew gives you the schedule, the methods and the way the homeowner is treated. Subcontract crews let you add and drop capacity as sales move, and they bring their own truck and tools. Each costs you in a different place: payroll and idle days for a crew, less say over the work and more checking for subs.
Don't go by the word on the paperwork; look at how the work actually runs. The IRS groups the facts it looks at into three kinds: behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship1. If you set a sub's hours, supply the tools and pay by the hour, ask your accountant whether you really have an employee. Your state may look at it differently, so settle it with an accountant or employment lawyer before anyone starts. This is general information, not tax or legal advice.
If you're a roofer or remodeler adding windows, the same choice comes up with a twist; see adding windows to a roofing business.
Your own crew or subcontractors: what changes
Who decides how and when the work is done
- Your own crew
- You: methods, hours and the order of jobs
- Subcontract crew
- Mostly the sub, inside what your agreement says
What a slow month costs
- Your own crew
- Payroll keeps running unless you cut hours
- Subcontract crew
- Little: you book fewer jobs
Truck, tools and disposal
- Your own crew
- Usually yours to buy and run
- Subcontract crew
- Usually theirs; put it in writing
Insurance to check
- Your own crew
- Your own policies; ask your agent what your crew needs
- Subcontract crew
- Their certificates, current and for this kind of work, checked every season
Training on your product
- Your own crew
- You train once and it stays in the company
- Subcontract crew
- You train each crew, and some install for other dealers too
Who the homeowner sees
- Your own crew
- Your shirts, your truck, your people
- Subcontract crew
- Their people under your name, so set rules for dress, talk and cleanup
Best when
- Your own crew
- Volume is steady and you want one standard
- Subcontract crew
- Volume swings, or you're new and can't carry payroll yet
| Question | Your own crew | Subcontract crew |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides how and when the work is done | You: methods, hours and the order of jobs | Mostly the sub, inside what your agreement says |
| What a slow month costs | Payroll keeps running unless you cut hours | Little: you book fewer jobs |
| Truck, tools and disposal | Usually yours to buy and run | Usually theirs; put it in writing |
| Insurance to check | Your own policies; ask your agent what your crew needs | Their certificates, current and for this kind of work, checked every season |
| Training on your product | You train once and it stays in the company | You train each crew, and some install for other dealers too |
| Who the homeowner sees | Your shirts, your truck, your people | Their people under your name, so set rules for dress, talk and cleanup |
| Best when | Volume is steady and you want one standard | Volume swings, or you're new and can't carry payroll yet |
What should you check before you hire a window installer?
Check what a careful homeowner will check, then what only you will notice. The FTC tells homeowners to consider only licensed and insured contractors, to check the license with their state or county, and to ask for proof of insurance3. When your sub is standing on their porch, your company's name is on the contract, so their paperwork is your paperwork.
For a benchmark, look at what one national brand asks of its subs. Renewal by Andersen says on its installer application that subcontract crews need $1 million per occurrence of general liability, $1 million of auto liability, workers' comp at the statutory limit, a Certified Lead Renovator certificate, their own truck, trailer and tools, at least three years of window and remodeling experience, and a crew of at least two4. Your own limits are a question for your insurance agent, but a list that specific is a good model for yours.
Your state may also have rules for the subcontract itself. California, for example, requires a licensed contractor to put its license number in its construction contracts and its subcontracts5. Ask your state's contractor board before you write your first one.
- License: the right one for this work in your state and city, in the name of the person or company you're paying, and current.
- Insurance: certificates sent by their agent, not a photo of a card, for liability and for workers' comp if they have their own workers. Put the end dates on your calendar. Ask your own agent what limits to require and whether to be listed on their policy.
- Product experience: which brands and frame materials they've installed, and which methods: an insert into the old frame, or a full-frame tear-out to the rough opening. Ask how they'd do your typical house.
- References from a homeowner and from a dealer they've installed for. The dealer will tell you about callbacks; the homeowner will tell you about cleanup.
- Photos of their own past installs, inside and out, and the address of a recent one you can drive past.
- Capacity: how many openings a day they do on your kind of job, how far out they're booked, and who else they install for.
- Lead-safe paperwork if you work on homes built before 1978: a current renovator certificate for whoever leads the crew and, for a sub, their own firm certification. Both are explained further down.
Phone screen for an installer or a sub crew
Tell me about the last three jobs you did. What windows, what kind of house, insert or full-frame?
You pull the old window and the sill is soft. What do you do next, and who do you call?
Who's on your crew, and who's in charge on the job when you're not there?
Can your agent email me your insurance certificates this week?
Is your company EPA lead-safe certified, and who on your crew is a certified renovator? Send me both certificates with the insurance.
Who can I call? One homeowner and one dealer you've installed for.
A window you put in starts leaking a year later. What happens?
Listen for specifics: brands, methods, what went wrong and how they fixed it. A vague answer to the soft-sill question is the one to worry about.
How do you test a window installer before giving them jobs?
Pay for a tryout. Give a new installer or crew one real job, or a few openings on one, with your product, and be there for it. An interview tells you how someone talks about installing windows. A morning on a job tells you how they install them, and how they treat the house and the family in it.
Read the maker's installation instructions first so you know what you're watching for. They're specific. Ply Gem's guidance, for example, says not to install unless temperatures will stay above freezing for the next 24 hours so sealants can cure, and not to install onto wet or frosty surfaces6. The installer you want knows the instructions for your brand and follows them when nobody's checking.
Tryout scorecard
Arrival and setup
- Good sign
- On time, introduces themselves, puts down drop cloths, asks where to stage
- Red flag
- Walks in and starts pulling trim
Taking out the old window
- Good sign
- Removes stops and sashes without wrecking trim that's staying
- Red flag
- Splits casing that was supposed to be reused
Checking the opening
- Good sign
- Looks for rot and water damage, checks level, plumb and square, and tells you before covering anything
- Red flag
- Covers damage and moves on
Setting the window
- Good sign
- Shims and fastens where the instructions say, and checks that every sash opens and locks before insulating
- Red flag
- Skips the operation check, or fastens where the instructions don't allow
Insulating and sealing
- Good sign
- Uses the foam or insulation the maker calls for and seals the outside so water runs off
- Red flag
- Overfills with the wrong foam until the frame bows, or leaves gaps
Finish and cleanup
- Good sign
- Tight trim, neat caulk, the window labels kept for the homeowner, the floor vacuumed
- Red flag
- Dust, cut-offs and old caulk left behind
Talking to the homeowner
- Good sign
- Shows how each window opens, locks and gets cleaned
- Red flag
- Leaves without a word
| What to watch | Good sign | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Arrival and setup | On time, introduces themselves, puts down drop cloths, asks where to stage | Walks in and starts pulling trim |
| Taking out the old window | Removes stops and sashes without wrecking trim that's staying | Splits casing that was supposed to be reused |
| Checking the opening | Looks for rot and water damage, checks level, plumb and square, and tells you before covering anything | Covers damage and moves on |
| Setting the window | Shims and fastens where the instructions say, and checks that every sash opens and locks before insulating | Skips the operation check, or fastens where the instructions don't allow |
| Insulating and sealing | Uses the foam or insulation the maker calls for and seals the outside so water runs off | Overfills with the wrong foam until the frame bows, or leaves gaps |
| Finish and cleanup | Tight trim, neat caulk, the window labels kept for the homeowner, the floor vacuumed | Dust, cut-offs and old caulk left behind |
| Talking to the homeowner | Shows how each window opens, locks and gets cleaned | Leaves without a word |
How do window installers get paid?
Rates vary by market, crew and job, so this guide doesn't quote one; ask a few local crews and your supplier's rep what's normal where you work. What matters more than the rate is that both sides know exactly what it covers before the first job. How install cost goes into your price is in how to price window replacement jobs.
There are three common ways to pay, compared in the table below. Whichever you choose, put these in writing:
- What's included: removal, hauling away the old windows, interior and exterior trim, caulk and cleanup.
- What counts as extra, and who approves it on the job before the work is done.
- When you pay: after you or the homeowner sign off the finished job, on a set schedule.
- Callbacks: who goes back for a leak or a sticking sash, how fast, and whether that trip is paid.
- Damage: who pays when a crew cracks a sill or scratches a floor.
- Lead-safe jobs: whether the extra setup, containment and cleanup time on a pre-1978 house is paid as an add-on.
- For employees, check the wage and overtime rules for your state with your accountant.
Three ways to pay an install crew
The opening
- How it works
- A set amount per window or door, with add-ons for extra work
- Works well when
- Your jobs are similar and you can price the extras up front
- Watch for
- Rushing to finish more openings. List the extras in writing: interior trim, exterior capping, mulled units, special shapes, second-floor ladder work, rot repair
The day or the hour
- How it works
- Wages for employees, or a day rate for some subs
- Works well when
- Jobs vary a lot, or the crew is still learning your product
- Watch for
- Slow days. Track openings per day so you can see them
The job
- How it works
- One agreed price per job, set before it starts
- Works well when
- Large or unusual jobs
- Watch for
- Arguments over what the price covered once the walls are open
| Pay by | How it works | Works well when | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| The opening | A set amount per window or door, with add-ons for extra work | Your jobs are similar and you can price the extras up front | Rushing to finish more openings. List the extras in writing: interior trim, exterior capping, mulled units, special shapes, second-floor ladder work, rot repair |
| The day or the hour | Wages for employees, or a day rate for some subs | Jobs vary a lot, or the crew is still learning your product | Slow days. Track openings per day so you can see them |
| The job | One agreed price per job, set before it starts | Large or unusual jobs | Arguments over what the price covered once the walls are open |
Do window installers need a certification?
Three different things get called certification, and only one is optional. Licensing is the legal side, set by your state and sometimes your city or county, and it may cover the company, the installer or both; check with your state's contractor board before the first job. EPA lead-safe certification is required for covered work on homes built before 19782, and it has its own section below. Installer training certificates are voluntary.
One voluntary program is FGIA's InstallationMasters. FGIA says installers earn it with a two-day class and a written exam, and the certification lasts four years before an online recertification test7. Some window makers also train installers on their own products. Ask a candidate which courses they've finished and when, then confirm the certificate is current with the program. Ask your maker or distributor what training they offer, and whether their warranty sets any installation requirements.
Training doesn't replace the tryout, but use it in the sale once your installers have it. Homeowners worry about the work, not only the price: JLC reads "I want to think about it" as a sign the homeowner fears an unfair price, poor work or a weak product8. Who installs, and how they were trained, answers the second fear.
At the table, when they ask who's installing
Our own crew installs. [Name] runs it and has been putting in windows for [years]. They've done [training] on this product.
They'll protect your floors, take out one window at a time, and show you how each new one works before they leave. They install the frame color and grilles you picked here, from the order you sign.
If anything isn't right afterward, you call me, not them, and I send them back.
Only say what's true for your crew. If you use subs, say so, and say who stands behind the work.
What do EPA lead-safe rules mean for window installers?
Window replacement disturbs paint. Stops, sashes, sills and trim get cut, pried or scraped, and in older houses that paint can contain lead, a hazard for the family and for your crew. EPA's Renovation, Repair and Painting (RRP) Rule covers paid work that disturbs lead-based paint in homes and child-occupied facilities built before 1978: the firm has to be certified by EPA or an authorized state, use trained renovators and follow lead-safe work practices2. Window jobs don't slip under it as minor repairs; EPA counts replacing a window of any size as a renovation9.
Subcontracting doesn't hand the duty to the sub. EPA says a general contractor that subcontracts the whole job is still performing the renovation and must be a certified firm, and that a firm whose sub breaks the rule is responsible for the violation too10. The stakes are real: in 2025 EPA announced that Lowe's agreed to pay a $12.5 million civil penalty over alleged lead-safe violations in renovations done by its installers, and to run a company-wide program for qualifying the firms and installers it hires11.
Three habits keep a window company on the right side of it, and the table after them sums up what EPA says. Some states run their own programs, so check yours. This is general information, not legal advice: confirm the details on EPA's lead pages or with your state program, and with your lawyer.
- Write the year the house was built on every measure sheet, so a pre-1978 job is flagged before it's priced and scheduled.
- Put lead-safe duties in every subcontract: whose certificates, who hands over the pamphlet, who keeps the records, and what happens when a crew skips a step.
- Price and schedule the extra setup, containment and cleanup time on covered jobs instead of hoping the crew absorbs it.
EPA's lead-safe rule for a window company: what EPA says and what to do
Your company
- What EPA says
- Firm certification lasts five years. Apply to renew more than 90 days before it expires, or it can lapse and stop you working until EPA approves a new one12
- What to do
- Put the expiry date on the office calendar, a year ahead
Subcontract crews
- What EPA says
- Both the company that contracts the job and the sub doing covered work must be certified firms10
- What to do
- Collect the sub's firm certificate as well as their renovators' cards, and file both with their insurance
The people on the job
- What EPA says
- A certified renovator takes an 8-hour initial course from an accredited trainer, then a refresher every five years, or every three if it has no hands-on part. Let it lapse and the 8-hour course starts over13
- What to do
- Name the certified renovator for each job in the job packet, and track every expiry date
The homeowner
- What EPA says
- Before the job, the owner gets EPA's Renovate Right pamphlet, with a signed acknowledgment or a certificate of mailing at least seven days ahead. If the owner doesn't live there, an adult occupant gets one too14
- What to do
- Make it a step in scheduling the install, and check EPA's timing rules for when it can be handed over
Records
- What EPA says
- The firm keeps the records that show it followed the rule for three years after the job. When several firms work on one project, one of them can keep the records15
- What to do
- Keep them in the job record with the photos, and agree in writing which firm keeps them
| Topic | What EPA says | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Your company | Firm certification lasts five years. Apply to renew more than 90 days before it expires, or it can lapse and stop you working until EPA approves a new one12 | Put the expiry date on the office calendar, a year ahead |
| Subcontract crews | Both the company that contracts the job and the sub doing covered work must be certified firms10 | Collect the sub's firm certificate as well as their renovators' cards, and file both with their insurance |
| The people on the job | A certified renovator takes an 8-hour initial course from an accredited trainer, then a refresher every five years, or every three if it has no hands-on part. Let it lapse and the 8-hour course starts over13 | Name the certified renovator for each job in the job packet, and track every expiry date |
| The homeowner | Before the job, the owner gets EPA's Renovate Right pamphlet, with a signed acknowledgment or a certificate of mailing at least seven days ahead. If the owner doesn't live there, an adult occupant gets one too14 | Make it a step in scheduling the install, and check EPA's timing rules for when it can be handed over |
| Records | The firm keeps the records that show it followed the rule for three years after the job. When several firms work on one project, one of them can keep the records15 | Keep them in the job record with the photos, and agree in writing which firm keeps them |
What should every install crew get before the job?
A complete job packet. When install day goes wrong, look first at the hand-off from sales: a note that stayed in the rep's head, a size that changed after the price, a color nobody wrote down. Good installers stay where the paperwork is clean.
Keep the packet in one place the whole crew can open on a phone. The tools for that, from scheduling to job photos, are in software for window and door businesses.
- The signed order and the maker's order confirmation, checked against each other.
- The final measure sheet, with the method for each opening: insert or full-frame.
- Photos of every opening, inside and out, taken at the visit. How to photograph a house for a window quote covers the shots.
- The render the homeowner approved, so the crew knows what the family expects to see.
- Notes: parking, pets, alarm codes, which rooms to start in, anything found during the walk-through, and, for a pre-1978 house, that it's a lead-safe job and who the certified renovator is.
- The homeowner's name and number, and who on your side they should call on the day.
Hi, it's your rep from the window company. The crew arrives tomorrow between 8 and 9. Here's the render of the look you picked, so you know what's coming: white frames with colonial grids.
RenderIf you can, clear the sills and move anything fragile away from the windows tonight. The crew lead will walk through with you before they start.
Great, we'll be ready. Will they need to get into the upstairs bedrooms?
Yes, every room with a window on the order. They'll put down covers first and show you how each window works before they leave.
Where the render fits for install crews
In the job packet. The render is what the homeowner said yes to: their own house or room with the frame color and grilles they picked. Put it in the job folder next to the order, so the crew lead knows what the family expects to see when the truck pulls away.
Use it twice before anything comes out of a wall. Text it to the homeowner the day before, so they remember what's coming. When the windows arrive, check the labels against the order and glance at the render, which catches the obvious mix-up, like white units on a job sold in black.
Keep the roles straight: the order is the spec, and the render is a preview of the look. Screen colors are close, not exact, and each window keeps its current style, so no crew should ever install from a render. If your installers also quote small jobs, they can make one at the door: one photo, the frame and color, and 30 seconds later the homeowner is looking at their own house.







