Updated

Window replacement lead companies: how to pick one and judge it

The short answer

Window replacement lead companies sell you the details of homeowners who asked for a quote, either shared with other companies or exclusive to you, by the lead or by the call. None is right for every company. Judge each one on what it costs per set appointment and per sale, not the price per lead: Elevarus, a lead seller, estimates a $95 shared windows lead works out to about $220 to $310 per sat appointment1. Test one seller at a time, reach every lead within minutes, and keep only what turns into sales.

Photo of a red brick bungalow with burgundy window frames
Render of the same brick bungalow with white colonial-grid windows in place of the burgundy frames
Render: white windows with colonial grids in place of the burgundy frames, same window layout. Drag to compare. Photo: M J Richardson, CC BY-SA 2.0 · render shared under the same license

What kinds of window lead companies are there?

Window companies get pitched by lead sellers all the time. Under all the different names, most sell one of four things, and how you pay and who else gets the same homeowner matter more than the brand on the invoice.

You'll hear names like Angi, HomeAdvisor, Modernize and Thumbtack. How many companies get each lead, how you're billed, what counts as a bad lead and how you leave are set by each seller, can change, and can differ by trade and market. So this page doesn't summarize any one seller's terms. Ask the questions further down and get the answers in the contract.

Google sells leads directly too, through Local Services Ads, and you can buy clicks yourself with search ads. Those work differently and are covered in Google Ads for window companies.

The four kinds of window lead seller

Shared lead marketplace

How you pay
Per lead, often with a weekly or monthly budget
Who else gets the homeowner
Other companies get the same lead at the same time
What to watch
A race to call first, and homeowners comparing several quotes at once

Exclusive lead seller

How you pay
Per lead, at a higher price than shared
Who else gets the homeowner
No other company from that seller, though the homeowner may be asking others on their own
What to watch
How long exclusive lasts, and whether the lead is ever sold again later

Pay per call

How you pay
Per phone call that meets the seller's rules
Who else gets the homeowner
Usually just you while you're on the line
What to watch
What counts as a billable call, and calls for work you don't do

Appointment-setting service

How you pay
Per set appointment, or a monthly fee
Who else gets the homeowner
Depends on the contract
What to watch
Whether you pay for appointments that never sit, and who confirms them

Shared or exclusive window leads: which is better?

Neither, on its own. Shared leads cost less each and come in bigger numbers, but every company that bought the same homeowner is calling at once. Exclusive leads cost more each and the first conversation is yours, but exclusive only means that seller didn't sell the lead to anyone else. The homeowner may still have filled in other companies' forms.

Shared leads need speed most. Harvard Business Review reported a study of 1.25 million leads in which firms that tried to reach a lead within an hour were nearly seven times as likely to qualify it as firms that waited even an hour longer2. If nobody can call within minutes, during business hours, every day, shared leads will cost you more than their price says. The setup is in speed to lead for window companies.

An exclusive lead is worth its higher price only if it sells more often by at least the same multiple. If it costs twice as much as a shared lead, it has to turn into a sale twice as often just to break even. The example below uses made-up counts to show the check; run it on the numbers from your own test.

Example: does an exclusive lead at a higher price pay off?

Leads bought

Seller A: shared
40
Seller B: exclusive
20

Appointments set

Seller A: shared
12
Seller B: exclusive
10

Appointments that sat

Seller A: shared
7
Seller B: exclusive
7

Jobs sold

Seller A: shared
2
Seller B: exclusive
2

Leads it took per sale

Seller A: shared
20
Seller B: exclusive
10

Break-even price per lead

Seller A: shared
A's price (the baseline)
Seller B: exclusive
Twice A's price. Below that, B costs less per sale.

Calls for your setters

Seller A: shared
40 leads to work
Seller B: exclusive
20 leads to work

The first call to a shared lead

Hi [name], this is [rep] with [company]. You asked about new windows a little while ago. Is now an OK time for two quick questions?

Is it the whole house, or a few windows that bother you most? And is anyone else part of the decision?

Here's what I'd suggest. Text me one photo of the front of the house and I'll send it back with the frame color and grilles you're thinking about, so you can both see it before anyone comes out.

Then we'll measure and give you an exact written price. I have [day] at [time] or [day] at [time]. Which works for both of you?

If they say another company already called, don't knock the other company. Offer something they probably haven't had yet: their own house with the new frames.

Example: a text reply to a shared leadExample

Hi, it's [rep] from [company]. You asked about new windows today. If you text me a photo of the front of your house, I'll send it back with the frame color you're thinking about.

Sure, here it is. We were thinking black.

Here's your house with black frames, same windows, from your photo. Want to see white too? I can measure and give you an exact price Thursday at 6 or Saturday at 10.

Render of the same blue colonial with black-frame windowsRender
An example thread. No real customer.

How do you judge a lead company on cost per set appointment?

Price per lead is the number the seller quotes, and it's the least useful number you have. Score every seller on the same card each month, next to your referrals and your own ads. Two lines on the card only matter for bought leads: how many leads were bad, and how many of your credit requests the seller approved. The rest of the funnel, step by step, is in window sales metrics.

Watch the sit rate closely. Elevarus, a lead seller, estimates set-to-sat ratios of 45 to 65% for shared windows leads1. If a seller's appointments sit far less often than that, or than your referrals do, find out why before you buy more: weak confirmation calls, renters and tire-kickers, or homeowners who never meant to buy this year.

A scorecard for each lead seller

Contact rate

How to work it out
Leads you spoke to ÷ leads bought
What you want to see
Most leads reached on the first day

Bad-lead rate

How to work it out
Wrong numbers, wrong services, out-of-area and duplicate leads ÷ leads bought
What you want to see
Low, and falling once your zip code and job filters are set

Credit rate

How to work it out
Credits approved ÷ credits you asked for
What you want to see
Fair requests approved without a fight

Cost per set appointment

How to work it out
Spend with the seller ÷ appointments booked from it
What you want to see
Steady or falling as your team learns the source

Set-to-sit rate

How to work it out
Appointments that happened ÷ appointments booked
What you want to see
Close to your rate on referrals and your own ads

Cost per sale

How to work it out
Spend with the seller ÷ jobs sold from it
What you want to see
Comfortably below your gross profit on an average job

Average job

How to work it out
Contract value of the seller's jobs ÷ jobs sold
What you want to see
Not far below your company average

What should you ask a lead company before you sign?

Ask every seller the same questions, in the same order, and get the answers in writing or in the contract. A sales rep's "we don't really do that" isn't worth much if the agreement says otherwise.

Questions for a window lead seller

How many companies get each lead?

Why it matters
It decides how fast you must call and how many other calls the homeowner gets.
A good answer
A fixed number in the contract, not "up to."

If it's exclusive, for how long, and is the lead ever sold again later?

Why it matters
"Exclusive" means whatever the contract says it means.
A good answer
Exclusive for good, in writing.

Where do the leads come from?

Why it matters
Leads from the seller's own ads and sites are different from leads bought elsewhere and resold.
A good answer
It names its sources and says whether any leads are bought from other sellers.

Was the homeowner's form about windows?

Why it matters
A general home improvement form sold as a window lead is a weaker lead.
A good answer
Window-specific forms, and it will show you one.

How are leads delivered, and how fast?

Why it matters
Every minute counts on a shared lead.
A good answer
Right after the form is sent, by text or app, or as a live call transfer.

Can I set zip codes, job types and a weekly cap?

Why it matters
It stops you paying for repairs, glass only, storm windows and towns you don't serve.
A good answer
Yes to all three, and you can change them any time.

Do you check that the person owns the house?

Why it matters
A renter usually can't buy windows for the house.
A good answer
Yes, or renters count as bad leads you can return.

What counts as a bad lead, and how long do I have to ask for a credit?

Why it matters
A credit policy you can't meet in practice is no policy.
A good answer
A written list of reasons and a time limit your office can keep up with.

What did the homeowner agree to about calls and texts, word for word, and does it name my company?

Why it matters
You're the one calling and texting them. See the FAQ below.
A good answer
The exact form wording, and a consent record for each lead.

Is there a contract term, a minimum spend, a setup fee or automatic renewal? Can I pause?

Why it matters
When your install calendar is full, your lead spend shouldn't keep running.
A good answer
Month to month, no setup fee, pause any time.

Can I talk to two window companies outside my market that have bought from you for a year or more?

Why it matters
Other window companies' results are the closest thing to a test you haven't run yet.
A good answer
Names and phone numbers, without you having to push.

If I leave, can I export my lead history?

Why it matters
You'll need it to compare sources later.
A good answer
Yes, as a spreadsheet.

How do you test a new window lead source?

One seller at a time, with a budget cap and an end date, worked by the same people who work your other leads. Otherwise you'll never know whether the seller or the setter made the difference. Leave time at the end for the last appointments to sit and close, because a lead bought in week eight can still be signing in week twelve.

A 90-day test of a new lead seller

Before you sign

What to do
Write down cost per sit and cost per sale for your best current source. Set a test budget and the cost per sale you'd accept.

Weeks 1 to 2

What to do
Narrow the zip codes and job types. Log every lead: time in, first call, first conversation, set, sat, sold.

Weeks 3 to 8

What to do
Ask for credits on bad leads as they happen, not in a batch at the end. Listen to a few calls each week.

Weeks 9 to 12

What to do
Stop buying, let the last appointments sit and close, then fill in the scorecard above.

Decision day

What to do
Keep it, cut it, or change one thing and test again. Don't keep a seller just because it keeps the phone busy.

What do window contractors get wrong when buying leads?

  • Signing up with three sellers in the same month. When results change, you can't tell why.
  • Judging on price per lead, or on how busy the phone is.
  • Letting leads wait. A shared lead that waits until the end of the day has probably heard from someone else first.
  • Paying for work you don't do: repairs, single panes of glass, storm windows, or towns you don't drive to.
  • Asking for credits late, or never. A bad lead you don't report is a lead you paid for.
  • Treating bought leads as worse. A rep who expects a bad lead gives it a bad first call.
  • Sending the same first text as every other company that bought the lead.
  • Buying more leads to fix a setting problem. If sets don't sit, fix confirmations first: see window appointment setting.

Should you buy leads or build your own?

Buy leads to fill the calendar while you build sources you own: referrals, your Google Business Profile and reviews, your own ads, yard signs and past customers. Bought leads stop the day you stop paying. Your own sources keep working, and they don't go to anyone else.

Where leads come from in general, and what each channel costs, is in window replacement leads. How reps find their own is in self-generated leads for window sales.

Where the render fits with bought leads

In the first reply. A shared lead hears from several companies close together, and most of those calls sound alike. Ask for one photo of the front, or of the room they care about, and text it back with the frame material, color and grilles they mentioned. Each render takes 30 seconds, so it fits between the first call and the appointment.

It shows a real person read their request, and it gives the other decision maker something to look at before the visit. It's also a signal worth tracking: log which leads send a photo, and compare their sit rate with the leads that don't.

At the appointment, render their second choice from the same photo; afterward, text the one they liked. Each window keeps the style it has now, so present it as a preview of the look, never as a finished job. Your first render is free with no account, and a free account adds 3 more, no card needed.

Real before and after

Each pair is a real photo and a WindowRender render of that same photo. The caption says what the render changed.

Photo of a board-and-batten Craftsman-style house with an arched gable window and a covered porch
Render of the same house with white colonial grids on the arched window and the porch window
Render: white colonial grids on the arched gable window and the porch window. Photo: Robert Neustadter, CC BY-SA 4.0 · render shared under the same license
Photo of a kitchen with a large white-framed window over the counter
Render of the same kitchen window with white colonial grids
Render: white frames with colonial grids added, same view outside. Photo: Shixart1985, CC BY 2.0 · render shared under the same license
Photo of a two-story colonial with weathered wood siding and white grid windows
Render of the same colonial with black-frame windows and no grids
Render: black frames, same window styles, grids removed. Photo: Tim Kiser, CC BY-SA 4.0 · render shared under the same license

Questions

Are Angi or HomeAdvisor leads worth it for a window company?
Nobody can answer that for your market from the outside, this page included. Ask the seller the questions above, get the terms in writing, and run a 90-day test against your best current source. Keep it if the cost per sale beats that source; cut it if it doesn't.
Are shared window leads worth buying?
They can be, if someone on your team reaches every lead within minutes and your set-to-sit rate holds up. Judge them on cost per sale after a fixed test, not on price per lead or on how busy they keep the phone.
What is an exclusive window lead?
A lead the seller says it sold only to you. Ask how long the exclusivity lasts, whether the lead is ever sold again later, and where it came from. Exclusive doesn't stop the homeowner from asking other companies on their own.
Can you call and text window leads you bought?
Calls and texts to leads come with rules, and automated ones have the strictest. FCC rules ban autodialed texts to a mobile phone unless the owner consented first, and autodialed marketing texts need written consent3. In January 2025 the Eleventh Circuit vacated the part of a 2023 FCC rule that would have required consent to be given to one seller at a time4. That doesn't settle whether a shared-lead form covers your company. Ask the seller for the exact consent wording, check your state's rules and ask your lawyer; this is general information, not legal advice.
Can you get credit for bad window leads?
Often, but every seller defines a bad lead differently and sets its own time limit for asking. Read the policy before you sign, report bad leads as they come in, and note why each one was bad (wrong service, outside your area, fake number) so the request is easy to approve.

Be the reply they answer

Ask a new lead for one photo and text back their own house with new windows in 30 seconds. Your first render is free, with no account.

First render free with no account, then 3 free renders. No credit card. Then $1 for your first month of Starter.

How it fits a window sale: replacement window visualizer

Sources

  1. 1. Elevarus: elevarus.com/buying-windows-leads-cost-per-appointment-ben... · the company's own claim · seen October 22, 2026
  2. 2. Harvard Business Review: hbr.org/2011/03/the-short-life-of-online-sales-leads · seen October 22, 2026
  3. 3. Federal Communications Commission: fcc.gov/consumers/guides/stop-unwanted-robocalls-and-... · seen October 22, 2026
  4. 4. US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit: media.ca11.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/files/202410277.pdf · seen October 23, 2026

WindowRender is not affiliated with Elevarus or Harvard Business Review. Details about other companies and studies come from the pages above as of the date shown and can change, so check with the source before you rely on them.