Sales playbook Updated

Competing with Renewal by Andersen: a playbook for independent window dealers

The short answer

Compete with the visit, not the brand. Renewal by Andersen asks homeowners for 60 to 90 minutes and says its consultant gives an exact price in writing1, which its FAQ says holds for a year2. Its consultant brings samples and an augmented reality tool, Real View2. So don't rush them and don't knock the other company. Offer the choices you carry, an itemized quote that's easy to hold next to theirs, and a view they may not have seen: their whole room or house front with your windows on it, rendered in 30 seconds.

Photo of a living room with a wide white-framed casement window
Render of the same living room with a black-framed window
Render: black frames on the four-panel casement window, same layout. Drag to compare. Photo: Jarosław Ceborski, CC0

What did the homeowner see at the Renewal by Andersen visit?

Assume a thorough one. You can't compete with a presentation you're guessing about, so start from what Renewal by Andersen says about its own visit. Every row below comes from its pages or a job post, which means you can talk about it accurately and without spin.

A Renewal by Andersen visit, and what it means for yours

Time

What Renewal by Andersen describes
60 to 90 minutes, with all property owners present for the whole visit1
What it means for your appointment
They've already given one evening, with every owner at the table. Ask for the same when you book, say how long your visit takes, and keep to it.

Samples

What Renewal by Andersen describes
The consultant brings physical samples2
What it means for your appointment
Bring yours. A corner sample answers questions about weight and finish that a screen can't.

Augmented reality

What Renewal by Andersen describes
With Real View they can place a window or door in its room, open and close it, look through it and see the hardware up close2
What it means for your appointment
AR answers how one window works in one spot. Your render can answer a different question: how the whole room, or the whole front of the house, looks in the new color.

Presentation

What Renewal by Andersen describes
One job post, for Louisville, Kentucky, describes iPad presentations and a computer-generated proposal on the first visit3
What it means for your appointment
Expect a polished proposal already on the table. Yours has to be at least as clear, line by line.

Price

What Renewal by Andersen describes
An exact price in writing1, in a detailed estimate with pricing good for one year2
What it means for your appointment
If their estimate holds that long, they have time to compare. Don't invent a deadline to change that. Ask what date is on theirs.

Products

What Renewal by Andersen describes
Its AR tool shows its own windows and patio doors4
What it means for your appointment
If you carry more than one brand, material or price level, that choice is yours to offer.

Where can an independent window dealer win?

Not on brand recognition, and not by saying the other company's windows are bad. You win on things you control and can show the same night. Use only the ones that are true for your company, and make each one visible.

  • Choice. If you sell more than one line, put two or three options side by side at different prices, each with its own written price. A homeowner who has seen one company's products now gets to compare.
  • A quote they can lay next to the other one. List the series, frame material, color, grilles, glass, install method and everything included. They'll compare line by line, so make that easy. The full list is in when the homeowner wants other quotes.
  • The people. Who measures, who installs, who picks up the phone a year from now. If it's the same small team, put their names on the quote. If you use subcontracted crews, say that too.
  • Their own house. If they tried Real View, they saw one window placed in a room. You can show the whole kitchen wall, or the whole front from the sidewalk, in the color they're weighing.
  • Room to decide. The FTC lists pressure for an immediate decision among the warning signs of a home improvement scam5. A homeowner comparing two serious quotes notices who pushes.

What do you say when the homeowner mentions Renewal by Andersen?

Let them bring it up. When they do, be curious, not defensive. What they liked about the other visit tells you what they're really buying, and what they didn't get tells you where to spend your time.

When the homeowner says Renewal by Andersen has already been out

Good, then you've already had a thorough look. What did you like about their visit?

Was there anything you wanted to see or ask about that didn't come up?

If you kept their estimate, I don't need to see the price. Could I look at what's listed in it? I'll quote the same scope, so you can put the two side by side.

Here's something I can show you tonight. This is the photo I took of your kitchen, with the frame color we just talked about. Want to see the other color too?

Never guess about the other company's product, warranty or price. If the homeowner asks you to compare, compare what's written on both quotes.

How do you answer what they heard at the other visit?

These lines come up after a polished first presentation. Each one is a clue to what the homeowner valued. Answer that, and leave the other company out of it.

What homeowners say after another company's visit, and what to do

"Their frame material is something special."

What it often means
The frame was the main thing they were sold on.
What to do
Ask what they liked: strength, color, the look. Show how what you sell answers the same need, and compare the U-factor from the NFRC label of each window quoted, since ENERGY STAR explains that a lower U-factor means the window insulates better6. Make no claims about the other material.

"They showed us the window right in our room."

What it often means
Seeing it in place made the choice feel real.
What to do
Hand them your corner sample, then render the room and the front of the house from your photos, so they see the whole look at once.

"Their price is good for a year."

What it often means
They feel no rush, and they're right2.
What to do
Put your own honest price-hold date in writing and book a follow-up call.

"Their quote was lower." Or: "Yours is lower. What's the catch?"

What it often means
They aren't sure the two quotes cover the same job.
What to do
Go through both scopes line by line. More in the window price objection.

"They offered financing."

What it often means
The monthly payment is what stuck.
What to do
Compare the total cost and the written terms, not just the payment. If you offer financing, see offering financing for window replacement.

"We liked their consultant."

What it often means
They trust a person, not just a product.
What to do
Be that person on the phone the next day. Tell them by name who will measure and who will install.

How do you use a render when you're the second company in the house?

Start with the room or wall they care about most. Augmented reality is good at one question: how a single window opens and how it sits in its spot2. A render of a photo answers another: how the whole kitchen wall, or the whole front of the house, looks with the new frames, color and grilles. What the other company's visualizer does is covered in Renewal by Andersen visualizer alternatives.

Take two photos during the walk-through: the room they spend the most time in, and the front from the sidewalk in daylight. At the table, render the look they lean toward, then one alternative from the same photo. Each render takes 30 seconds, so it fits inside the presentation without slowing it down.

Render only what you sell. If they loved a color from the other visit, pick the closest color in a line you carry, render that, and say plainly that it's your product's color. The color picker lists standard colors and colors named after popular manufacturer lines, so pick from the line on your quote.

Example text, the evening after your visitExample

Thanks for having me tonight. Here's your kitchen with the black frames from my quote, from the photo I took. Same window styles you have now, just the new frames.

Render of the same kitchen with a black-framed window and the same view outsideRender

Your itemized quote is attached too, so you can put it next to the other estimate line by line. I'll call Thursday.

Thanks. Can we see the front of the house in white with grids?

Here it is, from the photo out front. Same house, white frames with colonial grids.

An example thread. No real customer.

What should you never do when selling against Renewal by Andersen?

  • Don't knock the company or its windows. The homeowner chose to invite them, and criticizing that choice makes you the one they doubt.
  • Don't guess. If you don't know what the other warranty, product or price includes, say so and compare what's on paper.
  • Don't suggest you're connected to them, and never call a render a picture of their windows.
  • Don't invent urgency. A price of yours that expires when you walk out the door looks bad next to an estimate the homeowner can sit on for a year.
  • Don't promise energy savings you can't back up. What's allowed is in window energy savings claims.
  • Check with your lawyer before you name another company in an ad. This page is about what happens at the table.

Where the render fits against Renewal by Andersen

At the table, right after the homeowner tells you about the other visit and right before your price. They've likely held a sample, and may have seen a window placed in the room. Now show them the whole picture: their kitchen, or the front of their house, with the frame color and grilles on your quote.

Then send it that night with your itemized quote. When they sit down to compare two serious estimates, the one with their own house attached is easier to picture, and easier to pass to the owner who wasn't sure.

Real before and after

Each pair is a real photo and a WindowRender render of that same photo. The caption says what the render changed.

Photo of a blue two-story colonial with white windows and white shutters
Render of the same blue colonial with black-frame windows
Render: black frames, same window styles, white shutters kept. Photo: Famartin, CC BY-SA 4.0 · render shared under the same license
Photo of a board-and-batten Craftsman-style house with an arched gable window and a covered porch
Render of the same house with black frames on the arched window and the porch window
Render: black frames on the arched gable window and the porch window, same window layouts. Photo: Robert Neustadter, CC BY-SA 4.0 · render shared under the same license
Photo of a kitchen with a large white-framed window over the counter
Render of the same kitchen window with white colonial grids
Render: white frames with colonial grids added, same view outside. Photo: Shixart1985, CC BY 2.0 · render shared under the same license

Questions

Should I bring up Renewal by Andersen first?
No. Ask during discovery whether they've had other companies out, and let them name it. If they never mention it, sell your own job.
How long is a Renewal by Andersen estimate good for?
Its June 2025 FAQ says the detailed estimate comes with pricing good for one year2. Terms on a given estimate can differ, so ask the homeowner what date is on theirs. Either way they can take their time: call the next day as promised, then plan a follow-up that runs for weeks, as in how to follow up window sales.
Can WindowRender show Renewal by Andersen windows?
It shows a look, not a product: frame material, color and grilles on a photo of the house, with each window keeping its current style. The picker includes colors named after several makers' lines, Renewal by Andersen's among them, but they are close matches, not that company's finish. As a dealer, render the windows you're quoting. WindowRender is not affiliated with Renewal by Andersen or Andersen.

Show them their whole house, not one window

Take a photo at your next appointment, pick the frame color and grilles you're quoting, and render it in 30 seconds. Your first render is free.

First render free with no account, then 3 free renders. No credit card. Then $1 for your first month of Starter.

How it fits a window sale: replacement window visualizer

Sources

  1. 1. Renewal by Andersen: renewalbyandersen.com/schedule-a-consultation · seen October 22, 2026
  2. 2. Renewal by Andersen: enewsletter.renewalbyandersen.com/2025/June/Window-Replacement-FAQs · seen October 23, 2026
  3. 3. Renewal by Andersen (careers page): renewalbyandersen.com/careers/490b6fe8-2c24-4094-b3a7-50527dc1c8fe/... · seen October 23, 2026
  4. 4. Renewal by Andersen: enewsletter.renewalbyandersen.com/2020/july/augmented-reality-is-here · seen October 22, 2026
  5. 5. Federal Trade Commission: consumer.ftc.gov/articles/how-avoid-home-improvement-scam · seen October 22, 2026
  6. 6. ENERGY STAR: energystar.gov/independently-tested-and-certified-energy-per... · seen October 22, 2026

WindowRender is not affiliated with Renewal by Andersen. Details about other companies and studies come from the pages above as of the date shown and can change, so check with the source before you rely on them.